Like this video

Ratings W12

W12.io - Blockchain Protocol

W12.io | Blockchain protocol W12 - is an open protocol for creation and execution of milestone based smart contracts. The protocol consists of smart contract templates (no programming skills required), DAO governance and a decentralized oracles network, that controls execution of the project roadmap. Such solution protects any fund contributor from intentional SCAM and unintentional failure, consequently brings trust and transparency between projects and token buyers. The fundraising campaign may be of any type: Charity, ICO – both utility and security, Crowdfunding and any other crowd sourced fundraise and governance. Fundraisers set up a DAO, publish a roadmap and work in according to it. The Oracles or community of token buyers check if the campaign is reaching the milestones and release funds in tranches, only when the milestones are met. The W12 protocol is designed to be easily integrated into any existing business, platform or organization. Inside of W12 ecosystem any of the parties can easily set up a DAO of the required type: contributor, receiver, fund or supplier. In addition, W12 provides a token sale platform, through which projects can sell their tokens and easily launch fundraising campaigns based on the W12 protocol.

4.0
17 16 expert ratings
Benchy 4.1
KYC
Experts
4.1
4.0
3.8
Review: download now PRO
Ended
Token
W12
Type
Price in ICO
0.0800 USD
Country
Whitelist/KYC
KYC & Whitelist
Restricted areas
USA
preICO start
20th May 2018
preICO end
20th Jul 2018
ICO start
1st Nov 2018
ICO end
12th Dec 2018
Visit ICO website
Report
Changelly

Ratings

All ratings published on ICObench serve informational purposes only. ICObench does not provide investment forecast, recommendations or any consulting for that matter. Thus, neither ICObench, nor the experts can be hold responsible for the visitors’ investment decisions. Read more
Igor Karavaev
ICO and STO and IEO advisor
Rated on Jun 19, 2018
Modified on Jun 19, 2018
2
1
1
7%

The vision looks ungrounded - "up to 95% of funds invested in failed projects are retained" and still "projects will be able to raise funds without initial costs and with 0% commission on the W12 platform" etc. Sounds like a number of attractive slogans not financially binded together in business planning numbers. Mainly looks like another project to get funds for creation of one more ICO consultant and decenralised exchange. No competitive analysis attached! The problem is the with team as well. For example, "Head of ICO projects department" - is a former realtor with a pedagogical education, I have checked Linkedin profiles. The founders also dont have experience both in ICO or blockchain. The team is too localised. After the second investigation I am worsening my rating.

+6Agree
-2
-8Disagree
Report
Oleg SharpatiyICO team member replied on 22 Nov 2018
Dear Igor,

With all due respect to your background listed on your LinkedIn profile, unfortunately, we found this review is looks superficial and unfounded. Perhaps at the time of writing the review you did not have the opportunity to study the project. The review does not present a technical analysis of the solution in question, nor does it highlight its significance for the entire non-profit sector and the market of crowdfunding for projects. We would like to note that we are not engaged in ICO consulting, nor are we creating a decentralized exchange. At the moment, our product is operational (one of the few on the market), and contracts have been signed with more than 25 projects regarding the use of the platform and protocol. We would also like to note that we do not have a head of ICO projects, and the appearance of such a position was possible in extremely early versions of the white paper, which were available more than 9 months ago. The team is diversified and has a wealth of experience in developing blockchain projects, as can be seen by analyzing the GitHub https://github.com/w12-platform. Based on the above, we would like to ask you to correct your review or provide reasonable arguments for further discussion.
Paresh Masani
Executive Director | Project Lead | Developer | Influencer | Advisor | Blockchain Lover | Influencer | Strategy and Vision Execution
Rated on Aug 25, 2018
5
5
4
7%

Great team - very active and very good social presence. Actively code commits done by experienced programmers in github.
Detailed white-paper with sufficient business and technical information.
I think W12 creates is a true decentralised system and blockchain use-case to help disputes management and settlement quicker at a lower cost.
Tested MVP - many projects already listed on the W12 platform so looking forward they raising funds using W12 platform.



+3Agree
+1
-2Disagree
Report
Juan Pablo Fernandez Aguero
ICO IEO Driver | CEO | Startup Advisor | Growth Hacker
Rated on Aug 5, 2018
Modified on Dec 6, 2018
4
4
4
7%

Team ★★★★
Vision ★★★★
Product ★★★★

The team is too localized and lack ICO and blockchain background. They need international specialists to get your fundraising goals and solve future challenges.
The whitepaper is full of standard phrases and there are hundreds of similar projects.

EDITED
Mark improved after read new information.

+3Agree
0
-3Disagree
Report
Nozomu Nakazato
ICO consultant
Rated on Aug 24, 2018
4
4
5
7%

The team is localized but has excellent counselors. Future growth can be expected.
Although the idea is not innovative, I think that there is not yet a strong rival project in this market.
MVP is wonderful, you can see that this team has development capabilities.

+14Agree
+13
-1Disagree
Report
Krutesh Shah
Enterprenuer | CEO | ICO Advisor |Investor | Blockchain Enthusiastic | Public Speaker
Rated on Aug 23, 2018
5
5
5
6%

Team: really good team with top rated advisors. Team has got lots of updates on github, you can see team is working really hard.

Vision:The idea is amazing. They are creating Kickstarter kind of website using blockchain where blockchain based projects can apply for funding. They are providing full ecosystem for business to raise funding.

Product: MVP is live and looks amazing. MVP is like almost like finished product.

Best of luck team. I will definitely follow the progress of this ICO.

+2Agree
+1
-1Disagree
Report
Aly Madhavji
Award-Winning Author | Angel Investor | STO and ICO Advisor | UN Consultant | INSEAD MBA | Advisor Polymath, BitBlock Capital, Fiat Capital Fund |
Rated on May 12, 2018
Modified on Nov 30, 2018
4
4
4
6%

A much needed project which can have a big impact on the industry. Looking forward to testing this out. Need to continue progressing with development and look forward to seeing updates

+2Agree
+2
Disagree
Report
Kyon Yoshihara
Direct Marketing Manager,ICO produce
Rated on Aug 30, 2018
5
4
5
6%

The team has been completed, and experts from each field are complete.
There are opinions that matter that the team is localized, but originally it is such a team. Discuss closely and, after making decisions, unite and do the work.
Certainly fraud is rampant and it is difficult to distinguish between projects that should be trusted and projects that are not. If transactions that do not require a trust relationship are done safely, I think that it is one point of arrival.
Token balance is well thought out, and MVP is better than anything else.

+8Agree
+8
Disagree
Report
Graham Doggart
Strategic Advisor, Founder of AuBit
Rated on May 4, 2018
4
4
4
6%

Solid project, few others doing similar offerings.

+2Agree
+1
-1Disagree
Report
Mohit Tater
Blockchain & ICO Advisor, Investor, Serial Entrepreneur
Rated on Aug 29, 2018
Modified on Aug 29, 2018
5
4
4
6%

The team definitely looks experienced and they have got some good advisors as well. Could use some more developers though. As for the idea, I like it and believe in it's potential but it will all depend on how well they can execute it.

Whitepaper is written well and explains pretty much everything they are planning to do. Best part is that they have an MVP ready with over 100 projects already listed.

+2Agree
+2
Disagree
Report
Yaroslav Belkin
Ex Cointelegraph and NewsBTC Media Group | Founder and CEO at Belkin Marketing
Rated on Aug 2, 2018
3
4
2
5%

1) Team looks kind of weak. No real blockchain or ICO experience from what I was able to find on LinkedIn. Very localized which might be a bad thing for such project. However, some points go toward them for the advisory board. Will this be enough is a question that still stands.

2) Presence of one sentence reviews on here make me raise a flag on a possibility of a review tampering case.

3) While I dig the idea and see that there is some clear vision of it, the project itself looks undeveloped to say the least. The whitepaper is filled with standard phrases and lacks details in my opinion.

+4Agree
+3
-1Disagree
Report
Oleg SharpatiyICO team member replied on 22 Nov 2018
Dear Yaroslav,

Unfortunately, your review looks unreasonable. We ask you to provide arguments confirming the theses expressed in it or correct it otherwise. On the technical side, the product is operational, you can test its main functions in test mode, but in the near future, the mainnet will be launched. https://test-network.w12.io/ As mentioned above, the team has extensive experience in developing similar solutions. The quality and regularity of updates to the developers’ code can be checked by anyone on GitHub, and not on LinkedIn, as you had specified. All other links to social networks are also public and open with histories spanning years. The white paper is worked out in detail and is convincing. Moreover, the website has a highly detailed yellow paper of the product.
Bas Geelen
ICO Analyst, Advisor & Investor
Rated on May 11, 2018
5
5
4
5%

interesting project with a large team (although I would like to see some more devs) and a good vision that moves with the market trend of accountabillity.

+5Agree
+4
-1Disagree
Report
George Erman
I am now open to taking on consulting roles, security tokens only
Rated on May 14, 2018
5
5
5
5%

Great idea. Team and vision is great.

+3Agree
+3
Disagree
Report
Zahid Imran
ICO expert and Advisor, consultant
Rated on May 14, 2018
5
5
5
2%
This rating's weight is reduced by 50% as there is no review added.
Hiromichi Yamamoto
bit-life, Japanese cryptocurrency news site manager and Japanese ICO angent
Rated on Sep 5, 2018
Modified on Sep 5, 2018
4
5
5
3%

W12 is widely represented at all possible conferences thanks to its huge road show. The fact that you can find Russian names inside the team does not mean the team is localised. Russians are excellent scientists and entrepreneurs. According to the profiles the team makes a brilliant communication at international markets.

One can check GitHub and see the number of the team updates there. In my opinion today it is one of the most active and live projects that besides solves one of the most important problem of the whole market. CTO has more than 10 year experience in startup incubator. Developers have a significant blockchain experience.

I like the fact that these guys pay so much attention to different communities in 20 languages. Such international way of making business is different from other ICOs.

+2Agree
+2
Disagree
Report
TO Brian
Acheteur Public
Rated on Sep 28, 2018
Modified on Nov 2, 2018
3
4
3
3%

Avantages :


- 1ère place au World Blockchain Forum, finaliste de l'ICO Race.

- Équipe hautement expérimentée.

- Les Tokens des fondateurs, de l'équipe & des conseillers sont gelés pour 2 ans.

- Un projet avec peu de concurrence pour le moment.

- Un hard cap assez bas.

- Si le projet fonctionne, permettra d'éviter au maximum les scams.

- Est utile pour les investisseurs comme pour les entrepreneurs.

- Tous les fonds levés par la vente du token d'un projet sont bloqués dans un smart contract. Mais l'équipe n'a pas accès à ces fonds jusqu'à la mise en œuvre de toutes les étapes déclarées dans la roadmap et la décision des acheteurs du token.

- Une roadmap claire.

- Permet le remboursement d'une partie de notre investissement si l'ICO listée par la plateforme est un scam.


Inconvénients


- W12 devra miser beaucoup sur le marketing pour développer son réseau. Sans cela le projet n a pas d'avenir.

- Interdit aux USA.

- Sur une précédente version du site , on peut voir que W12 estimait avoir 2 milliards de marketcap pour 2021 ce qui est sans doute un peu trop prometteur.

- Nelly Pankovichenko qui est RI et développement des affaires est une modèle photo, elle parle bien de W12 sur son facebook mais pas sur son instagram, on peut également trouver la photo utilisé sur le site w12 sur une site de vêtement. Nous avons donc du mal à comprendre ce qu'elle peut apporter au projet si vraiment elle en fait partie.

- Certains des advisors ne citent pas W12 dans leur profil.

- Pas de cadre juridique.

+2Agree
+2
Disagree
Report
Rob Miller
ICO Adviser, Marketing Expert, Entrepreneur in Blockchain and Online Projects
Rated on Jun 26, 2018
2
1
1
3%

I struggle to understand why so many one sentence reviews on here.

This looks more like a fund raiser than a decent project. The whitepaper just throws around phrases with no real facts.

For those that know me I like to look at teams and this one is poor. They have no real experience in this field. Did you all sit around a table and give each other job titles?

+2Agree
-2
-4Disagree
Report
Oleg SharpatiyICO team member replied on 22 Nov 2018
Dear Rob,

Your review consisting of 2 sentences does not looks solid. Perhaps it was inserted by mistake and without prior analysis of our project and the product in question. We kindly ask you to correct the review or provide valid arguments otherwise. We have a detailed White paper and a detailed technical Yellow paper. We have a test net and a working version of the product. The team’s experience includes: technical implementation for projects on the platforms Ethereum, Hyperledger Fabric (Composer) and BitShares. Technical support of ICO. Blocks: Ethereum, Bitcoin, Bitcoin Cash, Litecoin, NEM, Cardano, Stellar; Platform for creating crypto-derivatives; Hyperledger DApp application release, transfer from owner to owner, and delisting of shares, both ordinary and preferred. The application checks the legality of the transfer of shares by verifying the downloaded documents and KYC and many others. You can check GitHub, LinkedIn and other open profiles for more details.
Benchy
ICO analyzer bot
4.1
16%

Experts are independently and voluntarily contributing to the community. If no expert has rated the ICO, only ICO analyzer's results are used. Always research before investing as these ratings should not be taken as an investing guide of any kind.

Ratings and ICO analyzer results are being updated (re-calculated) every few hours.

Add to bookmarks
ICO KYC Report
3 members invited
Oleg Sharpatiy
Passed
Andrey Granovskiy
Passed
Aleksandr Tikhonov
Passed
KYC procedure verifies selected/specific team members only. It does not guarantee ICO success nor is a call for investment.
Missing or incorrect data? Let us know.

ICOs that might interest you

HYGH

HYGH is disrupting the digital out of home (DOOH) advertising sector with a P2P adverti...

143 days 0 hours left
4.1

Viaz

The utility of VIAZ is to provide a decentralized funding platform, connecting its user...

Starts in 21 days 0 hours
4.7

SaTT

SaTT tokens will be used to rules advertising transactions between advertisers and publ...

168 days 0 hours left
4.2

XR Web

Decentralized protocol for building and monetizing applications for the XR (Extended R...

1 day 0 hours left
Join Telegram!Join Telegram!

Cookies help us deliver our services. By using our services, you agree to our use of cookies.

Learn more Got it