Vanig

I think it is quite outrageous to aim to compete with Amazon, Walmart, Ebay etc. The team is good at IT but i dont see it fits the targets settled in the WP. Two kinds of tokens and some other perks from the WP seem not attractive as well. Profitable on the 2nd year? Does not look realistic

We've had e-commerce ICOs, we've had supply chain ICOs, but this is the first ICO (at least as far as I know) that combines both. I studied the project and it seems promising.
The only thing I am not a great fan of is the country of origin. However, the team seems legit, so it should be just fine.

The idea is great and Vanig has the right team to pull it off. I don't think they are really competing with the Amazons and Walmart's. Its a niche market with potential to become a large retail company in several countries. It would work well especially in countries where the supply chain infrastructure is suspect and traceability is a challenge. The ecommerce part of the project also allows users to purchase product with crypto and this greatly could people in countries like Kenya where M-pesa is widely used. Hybrid architecture using Hyperledger Sawtooth is a clever choice considering how extensible,secure and modular the platform is. Multi-token strategy is a great approach for a hybrid solution (supply chain and ecommerce) that Vanig offers.

I really like the presentation of vanig and its plan to have decentralized database for eCommerce network. I am more interested to see the collaboration on B2B network and BTC attraction with the product. Nice to see a product from the eCommerce stream I'm working on since last 10 years. All the best.

Selection of Nevis country raises concerns. Team seems to be having good hands on experience in the field of IT. How are you unique from other companies which are providing Track & Trace solution? Selling the solution once developed and marketing will be a big challenge as faced by most of the Start-ups, which have raised money since past 2 quarters. So an aggressive marketing would be required to make it work. Selection of Hyperledger Sawtooth is a welcome move and can yield promising results. Tokenomics is well worked out and the target collection of funds seems to be reasonable.

Where is the MVP? You're seeking to raise a hard cap of $20m with no product available to see? You've got some kind of random URL link there that's password protected. Why?

The idea is fine, but this is hardly the first company to try and solve this problem with blockchain and with this idea. The difference being that the team behind them has more e-commerce experience and have actual real working products.