Smathium

Dear ICOBench community,


Please note that before reviewing this project & ICO/IEO, I conducted my own DD : team background, competitors, project history, various analysis and KPIs, growth potential and a lot more factors.


Here are the results of this analysis :

- Team : A solid team with professional and experienced people. All linked to the project on social media. I wish more teams were like this one.

This is definitely worth a 5/5 for the team.

- Vision : This is not the first project of its kind but there is definitely room for several brands in the reward industry. I can't find the softcap in the whitepaper, it would be great to have this information somewhere.

This is why I am giving a 4/5 for the vision.

- Product : No MVP at this stage, which is not an issue per se. However, the github is empty so it is hard to estimate the work already done and what's left to do until the first Q2 releases. Moreover, the vesting smart contracts for the team members and advisors are also missing from the github.

For these reasons, I am giving a 3/5 for the product.

NB : I am of course ready to change my rating as soon as the missing information are updated.


I invite investors to conduct their own DD before investing time / money on any project.

프로젝트를 알릴 수 있는 활동에 많은 기여를 했으면 좋겠습니다.

사람들은 ICO에 부정적입니다.

투자자들이 가능성 있게 보는 코인은

이미 마음속에 정해져 있습니다.

전혀 다른 분야의 프로젝트와도 경쟁을 할 수 밖에 없습니다.

시장은 하락후에 다시 상승을 하는 시점입니다.

메이저 코인에 투자하여 안정성과 수익성을
모두 취하려 할 것 입니다.

프로젝트가 지향하는 비전은 분명 좋다고 생각합니다.

하지만 그 만큼 이미 많은 비슷한 프로젝트들이 진행중에 있습니다.

경쟁력을 갖출 방법을 모색해야 된다고 봅니다.

경쟁 프로젝트보다 더 나은점에 대해
구체적인 근거를 제시할 수 있어야 합니다.

본 제품이 출시하기전까지

다른곳에 많은 이슈를 빼앗길 가능성이 큽니다.

한 가지 좋은 사례로

저스틴 선은 여론을 이용하는 방법을 잘 알고 있었습니다.

The most fundamental and innovative feature of blockchain is to incentivise the participants of a business network. Decentralised Loyalty programmes are innovative tools in hands of network participants to get best out of it.

Profiles of team are satisfactory and presents a good business model. Whitepaper has adequate information pertaining to vision and execution. Looks pretty clear to me. The idea is simple and much sought for daily life. All the best on execution part. Expecting a better product from team. Awaiting more information from founders & team. Please update accordingly.

Disclaimer: This is not a financial advise. My opinions are of my own and should not be treated as investment advise or any of related purposes.

Smathium: Smathium Makes Us Happy

SMATHIUM is a blockchain-based loyalty platform aiming to solve the key challenges facing traditional loyalty programs. A decentralized Application (dApp) where all businesses can create their own loyalty reward programs powered by a single token.

SMT is an Ethereum based token nothing more...

WEBSITE:
Good looking and professional with important info clearly reported;

COMPANY:
There's indication of company based in Singapore, there's also registration number, being clear and providing as much detail as possible is very important! good work

TEAM:
All Team core has linkedin profile, where you can check past experience and general skill, but nothing super...

KYC: YES,Team leader Blockchain officer has passed KYC

MVP: MVP avaiable on store

DOCUMENT:
Whitepaper (ENG and KO) and explanation video are avaiable, maybe onepager too will be appreciated

WP is clear and we can find all important information about Smarthium, from problem to solution, business strategy and team explain the choices made too, this is important!

Token distribution is not so appropriate, and there is a vesting period for advisor and team, this is very important, great choise to avoid price dump when token will be listed on exchange

COMMUNITY:
- Great community in Medium, Facebook and Twitter

Summing up it can be a great project but i dont know how it's gone..
_______________________________________

TEAM: 2
Core team has minimum background to fill every necessary skill

VISION: 2
Vision of this project is simple and clear, do we need another project as like this?

PRODUCT: 2
Product is explained, MVP avaiable but it will be used?
_____________________________